| Draft Selection | Draft Source | Position | Player | Age | SI | Pot | Assignment | Team | Statistics | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2072, Rd #5 | Latin American Academy | OF | Jaime Elías | 22 | 76 → 77 | 12 → 11 | AA | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2072, Rd #4 | College | 1B | Jonathon Dunlap | 21 | 56 → 57 | 11 | A | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2072, Rd #3 | College | SS | Sandy Barbieri | 21 | 77 | 14 | A | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2072, Rd #2 | High School | P | Marvin Starnes | 18 | 47 → 49 | 13 | Rookie | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2072, Rd #1 | Latin American Academy | OF | Adrián Valadez | 18 | 49 → 51 | 11 | A | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2071, Rd #4 | Latin American Academy | 3B | Luis Amador | 18 | 61 → 66 | 14 | Rookie | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2071, Rd #3 | Latin American Academy | 1B | Juan De La Rosa | 19 | 62 → 71 | 12 | A | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2071, Rd #2 | Junior College | OF | Joey Carrick | 21 | 79 → 88 | 14 | AA | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2071, Rd #1 | College | P | Christopher Hart | 22 | 72 → 87 | 13 → 14 | Majors | North Tonawanda Royals | G 14, W 1, L 3, ERA 5.80, IP 35⅔, K 18 | |
| 2070, Rd #3 | College | P | David Penn | 23 | 58 → 69 | 11 | A | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2070, Rd #2 | Latin American Academy | OF | Mateo Guerra | 21 | 70 → 90 | 12 → 13 | AAA | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2070, Rd #1 | Asian Posting System | P | Kenichi Tsuda | 27 | 60 → 70 | 12 | Majors | Toms River Pirates | ||
| 2069, Rd #5 | High School | P | Jon Poli | 21 | 49 → 64 | 11 → 12 | A | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2069, Rd #4 | College | 2B | Isiah Graham | 24 | 68 → 88 | 12 | Majors | North Tonawanda Royals | G 22, AVE .156, H 7, HR 1, R 4, RBI 4 | |
| 2069, Rd #3 | College | P | Tanner Fingers | 25 | 61 → 76 | 12 | A | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2069, Rd #2 | College | OF | Bud Hwang | 24 | 77 → 91 | 12 | AAA | North Tonawanda Royals | G 3, AVE .333, H 1, R 2 | |
| 2069, Rd #1 | High School | P | Malcolm Pitts | 21 | 40 → 70 | 13 → 12 | AAA | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2068, Rd #7 | College | 2B | Adrian Erickson | 26 | 62 → 72 | 11 | - | - | ||
| 2068, Rd #6 | Latin American Academy | 2B | Lázaro Vázquez | 24 | 63 → 85 | 12 | AAA | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2068, Rd #5 | High School | OF | Joe Dennis | 22 | 58 → 68 | 10 → 11 | - | - | ||
| 2068, Rd #4 | Latin American Academy | 2B | Ramon Andrés | 23 | 66 → 89 | 14 → 13 | AAA | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2068, Rd #3 | College | P | Jason Egan | 25 | 63 → 91 | 12 | Majors | North Tonawanda Royals | G 57, W 6, L 1, ERA 4.55, IP 99 , K 51 | |
| 2068, Rd #2 | College | P | Blake Hannah | 26 | 77 → 93 | 11 → 12 | Majors | North Tonawanda Royals | G 235, W 5, L 13, S 1, ERA 5.44, IP 150⅔, K 67 | |
| 2068, Rd #1 | High School | 2B | Delon Cason | 22 | 64 → 87 | 12 → 13 | AAA | North Tonawanda Royals | ||
| 2067, Rd #8 | High School | P | Steve Fingers | 23 | 38 → 42 | 11 | - | - | ||